A Guide to the Best Turkey to Order for Thanksgiving: Tips and Recommendations

Hosting Thanksgiving can be a delightful experience, but choosing the best turkey to order for Thanksgiving can be a daunting task. To make this process easier for you, we have compiled a comprehensive guide featuring reviews and recommendations to help you select the perfect centerpiece for your holiday feast. Whether you prefer a classic free-range bird or a specialty smoked option, our expert insights will ensure that your Thanksgiving table is graced with the finest turkey available, making your holiday celebration truly memorable.

We’ll cover the best turkey to order for thanksgiving reviews later in this article. Meanwhile, check out these related products on Amazon:

Last update on 2024-07-06 at 20:33 / Paid links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

A Brief Guide to Ordering Turkey for Thanksgiving

Ordering a turkey for Thanksgiving can make the holiday season run smoother and eliminate the stress of last-minute grocery shopping. Whether purchasing from a local farm, butcher shop, grocery store, or online retailer, there are several options available to suit individual preferences and budgets. When ordering a turkey, it is important to consider the size of the bird, with the general rule of thumb being about 1 to 1.5 pounds of turkey per person to ensure there is enough for everyone, with leftovers to spare.

Many retailers offer fresh or frozen turkeys, with fresh turkeys typically requiring shorter cooking times and offering a slightly different taste compared to frozen varieties. It’s important to check with the provider to determine specific ordering and pickup/delivery deadlines to ensure the turkey arrives in time for Thanksgiving preparation. Additionally, inquiring about the turkey’s source, whether it is organic, free-range, or heritage breed, can help ensure you are getting a quality bird that aligns with your values.

For those looking for convenience, some online retailers offer fully-cooked turkeys that can be delivered right to your doorstep, ready to heat and serve. This option can save time and effort in the kitchen on Thanksgiving Day, allowing you to focus on other dishes or spend more time with loved ones. Ordering a turkey for Thanksgiving can simplify the holiday meal planning process and ensure a delicious centerpiece for a memorable feast.

5 Best Turkey To Order For Thanksgiving

01. Butterball Premium All Natural Whole Turkey

Indulge in a Thanksgiving feast with the Butterball Premium All Natural Whole Turkey. This top-quality bird boasts a juicy and tender texture, making it a delightful centerpiece for any holiday gathering. With no artificial ingredients and hormones, you can savor each bite knowing you are enjoying a wholesome and flavorful meal.

The convenient size range makes it easy to find the perfect fit for your table, whether you’re hosting a small family dinner or a larger gathering. The Butterball Premium All Natural Whole Turkey delivers a classic taste that will leave your guests impressed and satisfied, creating memorable moments around the dinner table.


  • High-quality all-natural ingredients
  • Delicious and tender taste
  • No added hormones or steroids
  • Convenient and easy to prepare
  • Versatile for different cooking methods
  • Perfect for special occasions like holidays


  • Higher price compared to other turkey brands
  • Potential for uneven cooking due to larger size

02. Willie Bird Fresh Free-Range Organic Turkey

Feast on the succulent and flavorful Willie Bird Fresh Free-Range Organic Turkey this holiday season. Sourced from organic farms, this premium turkey embodies superior quality and taste, making it the perfect centerpiece for your festive spread. With its tender meat and rich, natural flavors, this turkey is sure to impress even the most discerning palates at your dinner table.

Known for their commitment to sustainable and ethical farming practices, Willie Bird turkeys are raised with care and attention to ensure the highest standards of quality. Juicy and delicious, this organic turkey is a delicious and wholesome choice for your holiday feast, providing a mouthwatering experience that will leave your guests coming back for seconds.


  • High-quality and flavorful meat
  • Raised without antibiotics or hormones
  • Humanely raised on free-range farms
  • USDA certified organic
  • Healthy and nutritious option for meals


  • Higher price point compared to conventionally raised turkeys.
  • Limited availability in some regions.

03. Diestel Family Ranch Heirloom Organic Turkey

Bringing a taste of tradition to your Thanksgiving feast, Diestel Family Ranch Heirloom Organic Turkey is a premium choice for those seeking high-quality, humanely-raised poultry. Each bird is thoughtfully raised on a family farm using sustainable and organic practices, ensuring a delicious and healthy option for your holiday table.

The Heirloom Organic Turkey from Diestel Family Ranch offers a rich and succulent flavor that will impress even the most discerning of palates. With a texture that is tender and juicy, this turkey is a standout centerpiece that will elevate your meal and leave your guests craving more. Choose this exceptional turkey for a memorable and satisfying dining experience this holiday season.


  • Raised without antibiotics or growth stimulants.
  • Free-range and fed a vegetarian diet.
  • Non-GMO verified.
  • High quality and great taste.
  • Certified organic by USDA.


  • High price point
  • Limited availability
  • Longer cooking time compared to conventional turkeys

04. Norbest Natural Whole Turkey

Delight your taste buds with Norbest Natural Whole Turkey, a top-quality choice for your festive table. This succulent turkey is raised without the use of antibiotics or artificial ingredients, ensuring a wholesome and flavorful dining experience for your loved ones.

Featuring tender and juicy meat, Norbest Natural Whole Turkey makes a perfect centerpiece for any holiday meal. Easy to prepare and cook to perfection, this premium turkey will impress your guests and leave them craving for more. Upgrade your next gathering with Norbest Natural Whole Turkey and savor the delicious difference.


  • All-natural and free of artificial additives
  • High protein content
  • Low in fat
  • Versatile for various recipes and cooking methods
  • Source of essential nutrients like iron and zinc
  • Juicy and flavorful taste


  • Higher price compared to conventional turkeys.
  • Limited availability in certain regions.

05. Plainville Farms Organic Whole Turkey

I recently tried the Plainville Farms Organic Whole Turkey and was thoroughly impressed. The turkey was incredibly juicy and flavorful, with a rich, natural taste that stood out. The organic quality of the meat shone through in every bite, making it a guilt-free and delicious choice for any meal. Additionally, the size was perfect for feeding a family or hosting a gathering, providing ample servings with plenty of leftovers. Overall, I highly recommend this turkey for its top-notch flavor and organic standards. It definitely exceeded my expectations and made for a memorable meal.


  • Certified organic
  • Raised without antibiotics
  • Non-GMO
  • High-quality, natural ingredients
  • Delicious, tender meat


  • Higher price compared to non-organic turkeys.
  • Limited availability in certain areas.

Benefits of Ordering Turkey for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is a cherished holiday when families and friends come together to express gratitude and share a delicious meal. One of the quintessential dishes of Thanksgiving is a succulent roasted turkey, making it a staple on most dinner tables during this festive occasion. Many choose to order a turkey in advance for Thanksgiving to ensure they have the best turkey to serve their guests.

Ordering a turkey for Thanksgiving offers convenience and peace of mind. By placing an order in advance, individuals can secure the right size and type of turkey they desire, avoiding the last-minute rush at grocery stores. This also allows for better planning in terms of cooking and preparation, ensuring a stress-free holiday celebration.

Furthermore, ordering a turkey for Thanksgiving provides the opportunity to select the best quality bird available. Many suppliers offer fresh, organic, or heritage breed turkeys that may not be readily available in stores. This allows individuals to serve a higher quality and more flavorful turkey to their guests, enhancing the overall dining experience.

In conclusion, ordering the best turkey to order for thanksgiving plays a significant role in making the holiday feast memorable and enjoyable. Whether it’s for convenience, variety, or quality, ordering a turkey ahead of time allows families to focus on what truly matters – spending quality time with loved ones and savoring a delicious meal together.

Turkey Buying Guide: Tips for Choosing the Perfect Bird

Consider these key factors when choosing the perfect turkey for your Thanksgiving feast: size, type (organic, heritage, etc.), freshness, and whether it’s pre-brined or requires seasoning. Making an informed choice will ensure a delicious and memorable holiday meal for you and your guests.

Size Of The Turkey

Choosing the right size of turkey for Thanksgiving is essential for ensuring a successful meal. The size of the turkey directly impacts the cooking time and overall presentation of the dish. Selecting a turkey that is too small may not be enough to feed all the guests, while a turkey that is too large could lead to excessive leftovers. By carefully considering the size of the turkey, individuals can ensure that they have the perfect amount of meat to meet their needs, resulting in a delicious and satisfying Thanksgiving feast for everyone to enjoy.

Freshness Of The Turkey

Freshness of the turkey is a crucial factor to consider when choosing a turkey for Thanksgiving. A fresh turkey not only ensures better flavor and juiciness but also guarantees a higher quality meal for your festive gathering. Opting for a fresh turkey over a frozen one can make a significant difference in the overall taste and texture of the cooked bird. Additionally, a fresher turkey will also be easier to prepare and cook, resulting in a more enjoyable cooking experience. Prioritizing freshness when selecting a turkey for Thanksgiving will ultimately lead to a more delicious and satisfying holiday meal for you and your guests.

Organic Or Conventional

One important factor to consider when choosing a turkey for Thanksgiving is whether it is organic or conventional. Opting for an organic turkey ensures that the bird has been raised without antibiotics, hormones, or genetically modified feed. Organic turkeys are typically raised in more humane conditions and have a lower impact on the environment. They are also known for their superior taste and quality, offering a more wholesome and flavorful centerpiece for your holiday meal. By choosing an organic turkey, you are not only prioritizing your health and well-being but also supporting sustainable and ethical farming practices.

Brand Reputation

Brand Reputation is a crucial factor to consider when selecting a turkey for Thanksgiving. A well-established brand with a positive reputation signifies consistent quality, freshness, and product satisfaction. Choosing a reputable brand can offer peace of mind regarding the safety and reliability of the turkey being served to your guests. It also indicates ethical and transparent practices in sourcing and preparing the turkey. By opting for a trusted brand known for high-quality turkeys, you can ensure a delicious and memorable Thanksgiving meal that meets your expectations and impresses your guests.

Cost And Budget

Cost and budget are important considerations when choosing a turkey for Thanksgiving. Given that Thanksgiving is a time when people traditionally prepare a large feast, the cost of the turkey can significantly impact the overall expenses. By setting a budget and understanding the cost implications, individuals can make informed decisions on the size and type of turkey to order. Additionally, considering the cost allows for better planning and ensures that the turkey purchase aligns with the overall budget for the holiday meal, helping to avoid overspending and ensuring a more enjoyable and stress-free Thanksgiving celebration.

Turkey Preparation Tips

In the Turkey Preparation Tips section, we provide valuable insights on how to prepare your turkey for a delicious Thanksgiving feast. One essential tip is to make sure your turkey is completely thawed before cooking to ensure even cooking and juiciness. Thawing can take several days in the refrigerator, so be sure to plan ahead.

Another key tip is to season your turkey generously both inside and out with a mix of herbs, spices, and aromatics to enhance flavor. Additionally, trussing the turkey with kitchen twine helps it cook more evenly and provides a beautiful presentation when serving.

Properly basting your turkey while it cooks can help keep the meat moist and flavorful. Use a baster or brush to apply pan drippings or a mixture of butter and herbs to the turkey every 30 minutes during the cooking process.

Lastly, allow your turkey to rest for at least 20-30 minutes after it’s done cooking to allow the juices to redistribute, resulting in a tender and succulent bird that is sure to be the highlight of your Thanksgiving meal.

Roasting Techniques And Recipes

In the Roasting Techniques and Recipes section, we explore various methods to prepare a succulent and flavorful Thanksgiving turkey. Whether you prefer a traditional roast or want to try something new, this section will guide you through the process step by step. We’ll cover essential tips for achieving perfectly crispy skin and juicy meat, ensuring your turkey is the star of the holiday feast.

From classic herb and butter rubs to inventive spice blends and marinades, we’ll provide you with a selection of mouth-watering recipes to suit every taste preference. Learn how to brine your turkey for extra moisture and flavor, or experiment with different cooking times and temperatures for a unique twist on the traditional Thanksgiving bird. With our easy-to-follow instructions and expert tips, you’ll be ready to impress your guests with a perfectly roasted turkey that’s sure to be the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving table.

Discover insider secrets for achieving that coveted golden-brown color and irresistible aroma that will have everyone eagerly anticipating the first bite. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or a novice in the kitchen, our Roasting Techniques and Recipes section offers something for everyone. Elevate your Thanksgiving meal and create unforgettable memories with a delectable roasted turkey that will have your guests coming back for more.

Leftover Turkey Recipes And Storage Ideas

Maximize your Thanksgiving turkey by utilizing leftovers in creative and delicious ways. From classic recipes like turkey sandwiches to more innovative dishes like turkey pot pie or turkey tacos, there are numerous ways to repurpose leftover turkey into mouthwatering meals. Embrace the versatility of leftover turkey to create new flavor combinations and surprises for your post-Thanksgiving feasting.

When it comes to storage, remember that proper handling is key to maintaining freshness and flavor. Store leftover turkey in airtight containers in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. For longer storage, freeze leftover turkey in portion-sized bags or containers for up to 3 months. Be sure to label and date your packages for easy identification.

Looking for leftover turkey recipe inspiration? Consider making a hearty turkey and vegetable soup, a creamy turkey tetrazzini, or a flavorful turkey curry. Don’t forget about turkey fried rice, turkey enchiladas, or turkey salad wraps for quick and tasty meal options. Experiment with spices and seasonings to transform your leftover turkey into exciting new dishes.

Make the most of your Thanksgiving turkey by planning ahead for leftovers. With some creativity and resourcefulness, you can enjoy delicious meals well beyond the holiday feast. Whether you prefer classic comfort foods or bold new flavors, there are endless possibilities for turning leftover turkey into memorable dishes.


What Are The Factors To Consider When Choosing The Best Turkey To Order For Thanksgiving?

When choosing the best turkey for Thanksgiving, consider the size of the bird to ensure it will feed your guests adequately. Additionally, opt for a turkey that is raised ethically and sustainably if possible, as this can impact the taste and quality of the meat. Look for locally sourced or organic options for a fresher and more flavorful bird. Lastly, consider whether you want a fresh or frozen turkey based on your cooking timeline and preferences. Quality, size, and sourcing are key factors to consider when ordering a turkey for Thanksgiving.

How Can I Ensure That The Turkey I Order Will Be Fresh And Of High Quality?

To ensure that the turkey you order is fresh and of high quality, consider purchasing it from a reputable butcher or specialty market known for their quality meats. You can also inquire about the turkey’s sourcing and ask if it is free-range or organic for higher quality assurance. Additionally, check for a plump and moist appearance with no discoloration or unpleasant odors, indicating freshness. Lastly, confirm the return policy in case you are unsatisfied with the quality of the turkey.

Are There Different Types Of Turkeys Available For Ordering, And How Do They Differ From Each Other?

Yes, there are different types of turkeys available for ordering, such as heritage, organic, and conventional turkeys. Heritage turkeys are known for their rich flavor and unique appearance, while organic turkeys are raised without antibiotics and are fed organic feed. Conventional turkeys are the most common and are typically raised on commercial farms with antibiotics and conventional feed. These different types of turkeys vary in taste, appearance, and farming practices, giving consumers a range of options to choose from based on their preferences.

What Are Some Popular Brands Or Suppliers Known For Offering Top-Quality Thanksgiving Turkeys?

Some popular brands and suppliers known for offering top-quality Thanksgiving turkeys include Butterball, known for their premium fresh and frozen turkeys. Other reputable options include Mary’s Free-Range Turkeys, known for their humanely-raised and antibiotic-free turkeys. D’Artagnan is another well-regarded supplier, offering organic and heritage breed turkeys for a gourmet Thanksgiving experience. With these trusted brands, you can ensure a delicious and high-quality turkey for your holiday feast.

Can I Customize My Turkey Order To Fit The Size And Preferences Of My Thanksgiving Celebration?

Yes, many places that offer turkey orders for Thanksgiving allow you to customize your order to fit the size and preferences of your celebration. You can often choose the size of the turkey, whether you want it fresh or frozen, and any additional seasonings or preparations. Some places even offer options like pre-cooked turkeys or turkey breasts if you prefer a smaller meal. Be sure to check with the specific retailer or supplier you are ordering from to see what customization options they offer.


In conclusion, selecting the best turkey to order for Thanksgiving is essential to ensuring a delicious and memorable feast for you and your loved ones. By considering factors such as brand reputation, size, and cooking method, you can choose a high-quality turkey that suits your preferences. With our reviews and buying guide, you can confidently make an informed decision and savor a perfect Thanksgiving meal with the best turkey that meets your expectations. Choose the best turkey to order for Thanksgiving wisely to elevate your holiday celebration to a new level of culinary delight.

18 Reviews

Leave a Comment